Two listings both say "near Metra." One is in Elmhurst and the other is in Hinsdale. For a buyer who works downtown, that sounds like a tie. Try writing the name of the Chicago station beside each address. The Elmhurst trip ends at Ogilvie Transportation Center. The Hinsdale trip ends at Union Station. Now add the walk from each terminal to the door where your shift starts. You have a much better question for your next showing: Which trip actually fits your day?
Start with the train you would take home
Metra's Union Pacific West line serves Maywood, Bellwood, Elmhurst, Villa Park, Lombard, Glen Ellyn, Wheaton and Geneva. The BNSF line connects communities including Brookfield, La Grange, Hinsdale, Downers Grove, Naperville and Aurora with Chicago Union Station. Those are two starting points for comparing addresses across western Cook County, DuPage and the Fox Valley.
Pick a normal workday. Start with the time you can leave your workplace and check the next train that stops at your station. Then check the following departure. If a meeting runs twenty minutes late, how much later would you get home? Repeat the exercise for a Saturday if weekends are part of your work schedule. Use the current timetable for your travel date. Metra schedules and service alerts.
Test the trip from the actual front door
For a Maywood or Bellwood showing, walk from the house to the platform entrance you would use. For a Naperville or Aurora showing where you expect to drive, start the clock in the driveway and stop it on the platform. Check parking rules for the lot you plan to use. A map pin measures neither the crossing you have to wait at nor the time it takes to find a permitted space.
Put the tax bills side by side
Illinois directs property owners to local county offices for individual tax records. Ask for the parcel number and a full year's bill for each address. Compare the same tax year, record any exemptions shown and flag questions for the county before using a figure in your budget. In Kane County, the property inquiry can be searched by address or parcel number. Illinois property tax record guidance and Kane County property tax guide.
Here is a budgeting example. Suppose the two annual bills are $7,200 and $8,400. Divide by twelve and the difference is $100 per month. Those are illustrative figures. For your comparison, enter the actual bills, then add a separate line for parking and train fares based on how many days you travel.
A two-address worksheet for your next showing
| Write down | Home A | Home B |
|---|---|---|
| Address, nearest usable station and line | _______ | _______ |
| Door-to-platform time and parking cost | _______ | _______ |
| Downtown arrival and walk to work | _______ | _______ |
| Usual return train and next departure | _______ | _______ |
| Tax year, annual bill and exemptions shown | _______ | _______ |
Before booking a second tour, circle the one difference that affects you most. For one household it may be the cost of the second address. For another it may be whether the later train gets someone home in time for pickup. That answer is more useful than a blanket ranking of suburbs.
By Paul Tyree, CEO of Paul Luxury Homes.