A four-bedroom house in Washington Heights does not become a fair comparable simply because the listing calls it renovated. In the five verified closings reviewed for this article, sold prices ranged from $250,000 to $370,000. Only two public listing descriptions clearly placed all four bedrooms above grade: 9500 S Loomis Street, which sold for $250,000, and 10141 S Emerald Avenue, which sold for $355,000. The other records help explain renovation and price, but their public descriptions do not establish the location of every bedroom. That distinction should guide both buyers and sellers.

Paul Luxury Homes

What did the five verified homes sell for?

The table uses sold prices and closing dates displayed on the individual Paul Luxury Homes property pages on November 19, 2026. It also separates three different ideas that are often collapsed into one phrase: a home with several recent updates, a listing described as renovated, and a listing described as completely rehabbed. These are the listing agents' descriptions of the properties. They are useful evidence of how the homes were marketed, but they are not an independent inspection of the work or proof that a permit was required or issued.

AddressSold priceClosing dateRenovation evidence in public listingBedroom placement verified
9500 S Loomis Street$250,000Nov. 6, 2026Recently updated plumbing, floors, paint and carpetAll four described as above grade
400 W 96th Street$345,000Sept. 18, 2026Described as renovated; new furnace, AC, roof, gutters and garageThree bedrooms described upstairs; fourth is not clearly located
9332 S Bishop Street$340,000Aug. 12, 2026Described as fully renovated with listed roof, windows, HVAC, plumbing and electrical workFour bedrooms reported; level-by-level placement not stated
10141 S Emerald Avenue$355,000July 8, 2026Described as completely rehabbed in 2026Primary plus three additional bedrooms described on second level
9316 S May Street$370,000June 8, 2026Described as a renovation with updated kitchen and finished basementFour bedrooms reported; the fourth is described upstairs, but full placement is incomplete

Why is $250,000 at Loomis different from the higher closings?

The public listing for 9500 S Loomis says all four bedrooms are above grade. It describes the property as recently updated with plumbing work, refinished hardwood flooring, paint and carpet. It does not describe the house as a complete rehab. The home reportedly has 1,900 square feet, two bathrooms, a side driveway and a detached two-car garage. Its $250,000 closing price on November 6 is the lowest in this five-sale set.

That sale provides a useful lower reference when a Washington Heights seller has four confirmed above-grade bedrooms and targeted updates rather than a complete renovation. It still requires a property-by-property comparison. A corner lot, parking arrangement, bedroom sizes, system ages and the quality of the completed work can affect how buyers respond. The $250,000 result should not be treated as a fixed price for every four-bedroom home with fresh paint or new flooring.

Which sale best documents four bedrooms above grade and a full rehab?

The strongest match for that narrow question is 10141 S Emerald Avenue. Its public description calls the house completely rehabbed in 2026. It describes the primary bedroom and three additional bedrooms on the second level, placing all four above grade. The property page reports 3,750 square feet, three bathrooms, a finished walkout basement and a detached two-car garage. It sold for $355,000 on July 8 after being listed at $359,000.

Emerald is therefore the clearest example in this sample for a seller who needs both a renovation claim and documented above-grade bedroom placement. Even then, size matters. A substantially smaller home should not inherit Emerald's sold price solely because both properties have four bedrooms. A seller should compare above-grade living area, bathroom count, garage, lot, finished lower-level use and the documented scope of work before deciding how much weight to give the sale.

What can Bishop Street tell a seller?

The listing for 9332 S Bishop Street describes a fully renovated Georgian with four bedrooms. It lists work involving the roof, windows, HVAC, plumbing, electrical system, kitchen, bathrooms and appliances. The public page reports 2,206 square feet, two bathrooms, a finished basement, a two-car garage and a sold price of $340,000 on August 12. The asking price shown on the record was $354,900.

The description does not identify the level of each bedroom. That missing detail matters if the subject property has four bedrooms above grade. Bishop can still help a seller study renovation scope, reported size, garage and final price. It should be labeled as a four-bedroom renovated sale with bedroom placement unresolved until the original floor plan, listing sheet or another reliable record answers the question.

Why are 400 W 96th Street and 9316 S May Street useful but incomplete?

The listing for 400 W 96th Street describes an exquisitely renovated residence and identifies three bedrooms on the upper level. The property page reports four bedrooms in total, while the description uses the phrase "3/4-bedroom." The finished lower level is described as flexible living space rather than clearly identifying a fourth legal bedroom. The home sold for $345,000 on September 18. It supports a renovation and price comparison, but it does not establish four above-grade bedrooms.

At 9316 S May Street, the record reports four bedrooms and a $370,000 closing on June 8. The description presents the home as a renovation and says the second floor contains a primary suite and the fourth bedroom. It also describes an extra private room in the finished basement. Because the public narrative does not locate all four counted bedrooms with equal clarity, the safest description is four reported bedrooms with incomplete level-by-level verification. This is the highest closing in the five-sale set, but its price cannot be assigned to a four-above-grade layout without additional documentation.

How was this comparison selected?

On November 19, 2026, the Real Geeks MLS search returned 61 Washington Heights single-family records marked sold during the prior twelve months with at least four reported bedrooms. The search tool returned the 25 most recent examples for review. From those, five records were selected because their public pages showed an explicit sold price and 2026 closing date and used renovation, rehab or recent-update language that could be read directly.

This article does not claim that the five homes represent every renovated four-bedroom sale in Washington Heights. It does not infer renovation quality from price, and it does not treat the listing description as a permit record. It also leaves bedroom placement unresolved when the public description is incomplete. Seller credits, inspection findings and private transaction terms were not available in the reviewed pages and could change how a professional evaluates a sale.

What should a Washington Heights seller verify next?

Start with a room-by-room floor plan of the subject home. Mark every bedroom by level and distinguish finished basement rooms from bedrooms above grade. Then assemble the scope of renovation work with dates, invoices, warranties and available permits. The City of Chicago provides a public search for building permit and inspection records, but the city also cautions that its database may not be complete. Use the records to investigate a specific project rather than treating an empty search as proof about the work. Search Chicago building permit and inspection records.

Next, compare the subject home with Loomis and Emerald first if all four bedrooms are truly above grade. Use Bishop, 96th Street and May Street as secondary evidence for renovation scope, size and price while keeping their bedroom-placement limitations visible. This produces a narrower, more defensible comp set than grouping every four-bedroom result together.

For more local context, review the Washington Heights seller guide and the Washington Heights asking-price and closed-sale questions. If you are preparing to sell, send Paul Luxury Homes the property address, the number of bedrooms on each level and a list of completed work. We can help identify which sales deserve the most weight and what still needs verification before setting an asking price. Request a personal Washington Heights pricing review.