Paul Luxury Homes Homewood ranch sale comparison

Direct answer: did a basement change the recent Homewood ranch sale range?

In a six-sale Homewood sample verified on November 22, 2026, three-bedroom ranches with basements closed from $232,000 to $282,000. Their median closed price was $233,500. Three comparable ranch records classified by the MLS search as having no basement closed from $200,000 to $230,000, with a median of $212,000. That $21,500 difference between the two sample medians is useful when selecting comparable sales, but it is not proof that a basement alone added $21,500.

The basement group also differed in bathroom count, reported updates, garage capacity, bedroom placement and finished space. The no-basement group included larger above-grade footprints in two examples and one unusually low tax bill affected by senior exemptions and a senior freeze. Sellers and buyers should therefore compare the whole property before applying a basement adjustment.

Verified Homewood three-bedroom ranch sales

SaleBasement evidenceClosed price and dateReported living areaDated tax record
1644 187th StreetYes; full, partly finished in remarks$232,000 on Sep. 4, 20261,320 sq. ft.$5,945 for 2024
1413 Evergreen RoadYes; full basement with recreation room and office$233,500 on Aug. 26, 20261,234 sq. ft.$7,405 for 2024
1650 Willow RoadYes; full, partly finished in remarks$282,000 on Aug. 4, 20261,220 sq. ft.$5,800 for 2023
2524 Locust RoadNo in the MLS search field$200,000 on Jul. 13, 20261,400 sq. ft.$4,093 for 2024
18511 Argyle AvenueNo in the MLS search field$230,000 on Apr. 16, 20261,509 sq. ft.$1,133 for 2024; senior-related exemptions reported
18652 Martin AvenueNo in the MLS search field; one-level living in remarks$212,000 on Feb. 11, 20261,272 sq. ft.$6,164 for 2023

How the sample was selected

The MLS search was run on November 22, 2026. It was limited to closed single-family homes in Homewood, three reported bedrooms, ranch style and a closing within the prior 12 months. The search returned 22 records: 17 with the basement field marked yes and five with it marked no. The comparison then used the three most recent basement sales and the three most recent no-basement sales whose public records provided enough condition information to avoid treating an unknown feature as fact.

One more recent no-basement result was not counted because its public page did not include property-condition remarks. That exclusion matters. A seller analysis should not assume that a home was renovated, original or move-in ready when the source record does not say so. The public listing links in the table allow readers to check the exact fields used in this comparison.

The MLS search summary showed that the 17 basement records had an average asking price of approximately $247,259 and the five no-basement records had an average asking price of approximately $219,880. Those are asking-price statistics, not closing-price statistics, so they are not substituted for the verified closed prices in the table. The direct answer uses only the six displayed closing prices and closing dates.

What the basement sales actually show

The $232,000 sale at 1644 187th Street reported 1,320 square feet, two full bathrooms, a one-car garage and a full, partly finished basement. The listing remarks described hardwood flooring and basement living space that included a bedroom and a full bathroom. Because the MLS total was three bedrooms and the remarks placed a bedroom in the basement, a seller should not automatically compare this record with a ranch that has all three bedrooms above grade. Bedroom placement can change how buyers view the layout even when the total count matches.

The $233,500 sale at 1413 Evergreen Road reported 1,234 square feet, one full bath and a 2.5-car garage. Its remarks placed all three bedrooms in the main-level living space and described a full basement with a recreation room, office, laundry and storage. The record also reported refinished hardwood, newer windows in much of the main level and a 2023 furnace. This is a useful example of a basement adding flexible space without adding another reported bath.

The $282,000 sale at 1650 Willow Road reported 1,220 square feet, two full baths and a 2.5-car garage. The remarks described refinished hardwood, an updated main-level bath and a partly finished basement containing a family room, flex room, three-quarter bath and storage. Its higher sale price should not be assigned entirely to the basement. The bathroom count, reported updates, garage and presentation all belong in the comparison.

What the no-basement sales actually show

The $200,000 sale at 2524 Locust Road reported 1,400 square feet, one full bath, one half bath and a two-car garage. The condition remarks reported fresh paint, new carpet and new kitchen appliances. The lot-size field placed it in the quarter-acre to half-acre range, while the other displayed examples were reported below one-quarter acre. That larger lot category and the above-grade footprint should be considered alongside the absence of a basement.

The $230,000 sale at 18511 Argyle Avenue reported 1,509 square feet, one full bath, one half bath and a two-car garage. The remarks described a 2025 roof, a main-floor family room, an office area and a primary suite separated from the two additional bedrooms. This record demonstrates why a no-basement ranch can still provide more reported above-grade living area than some basement examples.

The $212,000 sale at 18652 Martin Avenue reported 1,272 square feet, one updated full bath and a two-car garage. Its remarks described all living space on one level, a bright addition that could serve as a second living area and a move-in-ready presentation after fresh paint and cleaning. For buyers prioritizing one-level use, that layout may compete directly with a basement ranch even though it offers less storage below grade.

Do not compare the tax bills without reading the exemptions

The displayed tax amounts range from $1,133 to $7,405, but that spread does not mean one similar owner will necessarily pay the low amount. The $1,133 record reported homeowner, senior and senior-freeze exemptions. A buyer who does not qualify for the same exemptions should not carry that figure into an affordability calculation. The other examples also use different tax years, with records from 2023 and 2024.

For a current decision, verify the parcel and the latest bill with the Cook County Treasurer and review exemption and assessed-value information with the Cook County Assessor. A lender's escrow estimate and an attorney's tax review provide additional context. Listing taxes are a dated record, not a guarantee of a future bill.

How a Homewood seller should choose basement comps

  1. Match bedroom location. A basement bedroom should not be treated automatically like an above-grade bedroom.
  2. Match bathroom count and level. A basement full bath can improve utility, but it is not identical to two main-level baths.
  3. Separate reported above-grade area from basement area. The public living-area field may not include all finished lower-level space.
  4. Document finish and function. Recreation space, office space, laundry, storage, ceiling height and water history can make two basements very different.
  5. Compare condition and major updates. Roof, furnace, windows, kitchen, baths and flooring can outweigh a simple yes-or-no basement field.
  6. Match garage and lot characteristics. The six records include one-car, two-car and 2.5-car garages plus different lot-size categories.
  7. Use closed prices, not asking prices. The relevant number for a seller analysis is the verified closing price and date.

Why price per square foot needs a warning label

Dividing the six closed prices by the reported living areas produces a wide range. The selected basement homes were approximately $176 to $231 per reported square foot. The no-basement examples were approximately $143 to $167. Those calculations may understate the practical space in a finished-basement home because the public living-area field may exclude some lower-level area. They also ignore condition, bath count, layout and lot differences. Price per square foot can be a screening tool, but it should not become the pricing answer.

Limits of this Homewood comparison

This is a small, deliberately bounded sample, not an appraisal and not a claim about every Homewood ranch. The market search contained more basement sales than no-basement sales, so the segments are not equally deep. Public MLS data are deemed reliable but not guaranteed, and listing descriptions represent the information submitted with each listing. Finished basement quality, permits, moisture history and exact above-grade bedroom counts require document review and physical inspection.

The closed dates span February through September 2026, and market conditions can change over that period. The sample also includes different tax years, exemptions, lots, garages, bathrooms and reported improvements. The $21,500 median gap should guide the next round of comp selection; it should not be copied as an automatic basement adjustment.

Next step for a Homewood buyer or seller

A Homewood seller should begin with the three or four closed sales that most closely match bedroom location, above-grade area, bath count, basement finish, garage, lot and condition. A buyer should compare the same features and inspect the basement for water management, ceiling height, utilities, exits and permit history before assigning value. Review the Paul Luxury Homes Homewood buyer and seller guide and the Homewood market questions page, then contact Paul Luxury Homes for a current property-specific shortlist or pricing review.

Source records and sample date