On November 18, 2026, a $300,000 ceiling gave Chicago-area buyers a choice between a three-bedroom Ashburn house asking $225,000, a five-bedroom Auburn Gresham house asking $279,000, and a two-bedroom Evergreen Park house asking $225,000. Those three listings alone show why it pays to search by the way you live. If your priority is an extra bedroom, start with the Chicago examples. If two bedrooms work and you want to compare the city with the suburbs at exactly the same asking price, start with Sawyer Avenue and Campbell Avenue.

Paul Luxury Homes

Six addresses to compare before booking a tour

We searched the Paul Luxury Homes Real Geeks MLS feed for single-family homes in each area with a maximum asking price of $300,000. The search returned 14 records in Ashburn, 41 in Auburn Gresham and eight in Evergreen Park. Those raw counts include records such as auction listings with nominal prices. We selected two records marked new or active in each area with a stated asking price above one dollar. The six examples describe particular houses and should not be used to estimate what a typical house sells for. The linked listing pages are the sources for the room counts, sizes and historical taxes below.

AreaListingAsking priceBeds / bathsReported sq ftReported annual tax (year)
Ashburn8037 S Sawyer Avenue$225,0003 / 11,415$3,147 (2025)
Ashburn3658 W 82nd Place$265,0003 / 21,097$3,378 (2024)
Auburn Gresham8019 S May Street$279,0005 / 22,500$3,164 (2024)
Auburn Gresham8616 S Winchester Avenue$295,0004 / 31,350$1,018 (2024)
Evergreen Park9333 S Spaulding Avenue$259,9002 / 21,238$6,664 (2023)
Evergreen Park9824 S Campbell Avenue$225,0002 / 1900$4,009 (2025)

Ashburn: what does the second bathroom cost in this pair?

The house on Sawyer asks $40,000 less than the one on 82nd Place. Both list three bedrooms. Sawyer lists one bathroom and 1,415 square feet; 82nd Place lists two bathrooms and 1,097 square feet. In this pair, the house with the extra bathroom also has the smaller stated area. Before assuming the more expensive house better suits a busy morning, ask which floor each bathroom serves and where the bedrooms sit. A second bath beside the bedrooms serves a different purpose from one downstairs next to a recreation room.

For Sawyer, the question to settle on a tour is how the larger reported footprint is divided. Take measurements of the living room, dining area and the bedroom you would use most. For 82nd Place, find out whether the second bath reduces the hallway traffic that matters in your household. If both houses work as they stand, ask your lender to model each price with the same financing assumptions. Paying for a feature you would use twice a day is a different decision from paying for a renovation you might undertake someday.

Auburn Gresham: do five bedrooms make a better fit than four?

May Street lists five bedrooms, two baths and 2,500 square feet. Winchester lists four bedrooms, three baths and 1,350 square feet. May asks $16,000 less. A buyer who needs two offices or space for overnight guests could reasonably put May first; someone who needs bathrooms near several sleeping areas might start with Winchester. The feed gives a total count. Ask for a room list organized by floor and for an explanation of how the reported square footage was measured before comparing these two on a price-per-foot basis.

Winchester's listing also illustrates how a historic tax bill can affect a first impression. It reports $1,018 for tax year 2024 and identifies homeowner and senior exemptions. May reports $3,164 for the same tax year. Treat those numbers as questions for the assessor and lender before using them in a budget. A buyer comparing two monthly payments needs an estimate appropriate to their situation. If Winchester moves up your shortlist only because of the advertised tax amount, get that estimate before rearranging your tours.

Evergreen Park: compare two houses without increasing the bedroom count

On Campbell, $225,000 buys an asking-price starting point for two bedrooms, one bath and 900 reported square feet. Spaulding asks $259,900 for two bedrooms, two baths and 1,238 reported square feet. The difference is $34,900, with 338 additional reported square feet at Spaulding. If you use a dining table as an occasional desk, the extra space might let you work without clearing dinner every evening. A floor plan or a short walkthrough video can show whether the additional area is actually where you need it.

These two tax figures deserve particular care. The Campbell page gives tax year 2025 while the Spaulding page gives 2023. Pull the same tax year for both parcels before drawing a conclusion about carrying costs. In the county portal, check the address and parcel, retrieve the full annual bill, and note any exemptions. Keep the original listing figures in your notes so you can explain why your updated comparison changed. Look up Cook County tax bills and exemptions.

A same-price test across the city boundary

Sawyer in Ashburn and Campbell in Evergreen Park both asked $225,000 on the search date. Both reported one bathroom and a 2025 tax figure. Sawyer reported one more bedroom and 515 more square feet. Campbell's reported annual bill was $862 higher, or roughly $72 a month when divided by twelve. That is a comparison of two historical figures. Sawyer's listing identifies homeowner and senior exemptions; Campbell's identifies a homeowner exemption. The comparison is useful because it shows precisely what to investigate without assigning a tax advantage to an entire neighborhood.

Take the same two addresses and try one ordinary weekday on paper. Write down where you would park, where groceries would enter, which room you would work in and when you would leave for your most frequent destination. Put a question mark beside anything the listing cannot tell you. If you can resolve a commute question from home but need to see whether a bedroom fits your furniture, spend your showing time on the bedroom. This exercise also helps you decide whether moving closer to your spending limit would buy a feature you actually need.

Which two homes would you tour first?

For three bedrooms and a straightforward price comparison, begin with the Ashburn pair. For more sleeping rooms within the stated ceiling, begin with the Auburn Gresham pair and verify the layout by level. For an Evergreen Park search where two bedrooms are sufficient, compare Campbell with Spaulding before expanding the price range. None of those choices requires assuming the asking price is the final sale price or that a listing is still available when you read this. Open the property links and confirm status before traveling.

If one of these comparisons fits your search, send Paul Luxury Homes the two addresses, your maximum price and the feature you would give up last. We can check current availability and help find alternatives if a listing has changed. If your larger question is which floor plan works before you get in the car, our bungalow and ranch comparison explains what to ask about entrances, stairs and bedrooms. Ask for a current shortlist and tour options.